Comparisons
Comparisons
There is rarely a single answer to “what is the best way to update?” Automatic updates are convenient but sometimes catch you off guard; manual mode gives you control but takes memory and discipline. Below we compare general approaches rather than specific devices, to make it easier for you to choose yours.
Unofficial firmware promises new features, but you pay for them with your warranty, reliability and peace of mind.
How to read the tables: they compare approaches, not products. What your particular device can do is explained in its manual, and if the manual advises otherwise, go with it.
Automatic vs manual updates
| Criterion | Automatic updates | Manual updates |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | The device checks for new versions and installs them itself, often at night or at a time you choose | You check whether a new version is out and start the installation yourself |
| Pros | Security fixes arrive without any effort from you, and there is nothing to remember | You can pick a convenient moment, read the release notes in advance and save your settings |
| Cons | A restart may happen at an awkward moment, and menu changes can come as a surprise | It is easy to forget and keep an old version for a long time |
| Best for | Most home devices, especially routers, cameras and smart plugs | People who like to stay in control and regularly go through their devices using a list |
Official vs unofficial firmware
| Criterion | Official | Unofficial |
|---|---|---|
| Where it comes from | The built-in update feature or the manufacturer's official website | Third-party sites, forums, files from strangers |
| Compatibility | Tested by the manufacturer for your model | Nobody guarantees it will work on your particular device |
| Warranty | Stays valid | May be voided, and warranty repairs may be refused |
| Risk of damage | Low if you follow the instructions | The device may stop turning on and can't be brought back without a service centre |
| Security | Security fixes from the developer itself | It may contain malicious code, and official fixes stop arriving |
| Our advice | Install | Don't install |
Update now vs wait a little
| Situation | Update now | Fine to wait a little |
|---|---|---|
| What the release notes say | Security fixes and patched vulnerabilities | Only a new look or extra features |
| What kind of device | A router, a camera or anything reachable from the internet | A device you need right now for work or study |
| Circumstances | You have time, reliable power and a stable network | The battery is low, you are travelling or the network keeps dropping |
| What next | Check the settings and password | Come back to the update within the next few days rather than putting it off forever |
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice on preparing for an update and updating your router, phone, TV, camera and smart home devices, plus the article catalogue.
- Tools
What to gather in advance: a charger and a reliable outlet, a network cable, your settings and passwords written down, a list of home devices and the manual.
- Problems
An update is stuck, the device won't turn on, settings are gone, no new version is found, things got worse or there isn't enough space.
- Glossary
Plain-language definitions: firmware, version, release notes, vulnerability, automatic updates, reset, recovery mode, bootloader.
- Questions
Answers about this guide, about everyday updates for home devices and about avoiding tricks that use the word “firmware” as bait.
Sources
- Device manufacturers' instructions (in general terms)
- Security recommendations for home network devices (in general terms)
- Proshivki Portal editorial material
These articles are written in general terms and reflect the editors' view as of the date they were prepared. Home devices update in different ways: some do everything on their own, others need you to open the settings, and menu items are named differently everywhere. The final word belongs to your device manufacturer's instructions: if they differ from our advice, follow the instructions.